What supporting materials to ask for in awards

The Awards Platform - Professional businesswoman presenting project

Written responses carry entries, but supporting materials can strengthen them, providing evidence, context, and credibility that text alone can’t deliver.

A customer testimonial carries more weight than a claim of customer satisfaction. A before-and-after screenshot demonstrates change more vividly than describing it. Data visualisations make complex results accessible at a glance.

But supporting materials can also create problems. Requests that are too broad produce inconsistent uploads that judges can’t compare. Requests that are too demanding deter participation or burden entrants with work that doesn’t improve evaluation. And materials that judges don’t have time to review waste everyone’s effort.

The goal is requesting materials that help judges evaluate entries, in formats judges can actually use, without creating unnecessary burden for entrants or reviewers.

This guide covers what supporting materials to request, what to avoid, how to specify requirements clearly, and how to handle materials effectively throughout the judging process.

The purpose of supporting materials

Before deciding what to request, clarify what you want materials to accomplish.

Providing evidence

The primary purpose. Supporting materials substantiate claims made in written responses. Metrics dashboards confirm reported numbers. Customer testimonials validate satisfaction claims. Third-party reports verify independent recognition. Media coverage demonstrates external visibility.

Evidence materials answer the question: how do we know this is true?

Demonstrating work quality

For creative, design, or visual categories, the work itself may be the best evidence. Campaign imagery, product screenshots, video content, or design assets show what words can only describe.

These materials answer the question: what does this actually look like?

Providing context

Some materials help judges understand context that’s difficult to convey in text. Organisational charts clarify team structures. Process diagrams explain methodologies. Timeline visualisations show project evolution.

Context materials answer the question: what’s the bigger picture?

Adding credibility

Certain materials signal credibility beyond their informational content. Audit statements from reputable firms. Recognition from respected bodies. Endorsements from known figures. These materials don’t just provide information, they provide validation.

Credibility materials answer the question: who else confirms this?

What to ask for: materials that help judges

Effective supporting materials are easy to review, directly relevant to evaluation criteria, and add value beyond written responses.

Data and metrics summaries

Summaries of key metrics, presented clearly, not as raw data, help judges verify quantitative claims. Dashboard screenshots, summary tables, or visualisations that highlight relevant numbers work well.

What works: A one-page summary showing customer satisfaction scores over time, with clear labelling and comparison to benchmarks.

What doesn’t: A 50-page analytics export that judges must interpret themselves.

Visual evidence of work

For work with visual components, images or screenshots demonstrate quality directly. Product interfaces, campaign creative, design outputs, or physical deliverables are often better shown than described.

What works: 3–5 high-quality images showing key aspects of the work, with brief captions explaining what each shows.

What doesn’t: Dozens of images without context or organisation.

Customer or stakeholder testimonials

Direct quotes from people who experienced the work firsthand provide credible third-party validation. Brief, specific testimonials are more valuable than lengthy general endorsements.

What works: 2–3 testimonials of 50–100 words each, attributed to named individuals with their role and organisation.

What doesn’t: Anonymous quotes or generic praise without specifics.

Before-and-after comparisons

Comparisons showing the situation before and after the work demonstrate change tangibly. These might be screenshots, metrics summaries, process diagrams, or other formats that show transformation.

What works: Side-by-side comparison clearly labelled with dates and context.

What doesn’t: “Before” and “after” materials in different formats that can’t be easily compared.

Third-party validation

Independent recognition strengthens credibility. This might include awards from other bodies, analyst mentions, media coverage, certification documentation, or audit statements.

What works: Relevant excerpts or summaries with source attribution.

What doesn’t: Extensive documentation that judges won’t read.

Brief video content

For work that’s difficult to capture in images, events, experiences, demonstrations, short video can be valuable. Emphasis on short: judges won’t watch lengthy content.

What works: 60–90 second video highlighting key moments or demonstrating functionality.

What doesn’t: 10-minute documentary that judges will skip.

What not to ask for: materials that don’t help

Some material requests create burden without improving evaluation. Avoid these common mistakes.

Extensive documentation judges won’t read

Judges evaluating dozens of entries don’t have time for lengthy documents. Requesting full reports, comprehensive case studies, or detailed technical documentation produces materials that get skimmed at best, ignored at worst.

If detailed documentation is genuinely relevant, request a summary or executive overview rather than the complete document.

Materials that repeat written responses

Supporting materials should add value beyond the entry text. If materials simply restate what’s already in written responses, a PDF version of the entry, a presentation covering the same points, they don’t help judges and waste entrant effort.

Request materials that provide evidence, visual demonstration, or validation that text can’t deliver.

Raw data without interpretation

Raw data exports, unprocessed analytics, or comprehensive datasets require judges to do analytical work. Most judges won’t. Even if they try, they’ll interpret data differently, introducing inconsistency.

Request summarised, interpreted data that highlights relevant findings rather than raw material judges must process.

Confidential information entrants shouldn’t share

Requests for sensitive financial details, proprietary methodologies, or confidential customer information may deter participation or put entrants in difficult positions. Consider what’s genuinely necessary versus what would be nice to have.

If sensitive information is needed, explain how it will be protected and who will access it.

Materials in inaccessible formats

Unusual file formats, large files that take forever to download, or materials requiring specialised software to view create friction for judges. Some simply won’t bother.
Stick to common formats that any judge can access without special tools.

Open-ended “anything else” uploads

Invitations to “upload any additional materials you think relevant” produce inconsistent results. Some entrants upload nothing; others upload everything. Comparability suffers, and judges face unpredictable material volumes.

If you want additional materials, specify what types would be valuable.

Specifying requirements clearly

Ambiguous material requests produce inconsistent submissions. Clear specifications ensure entrants provide what you need in formats you can use.

Specify what you want

Don’t just request “supporting materials.” Identify what types of materials would be valuable and why.
Vague: “Upload supporting documentation.”
Clear: “Upload evidence supporting your claimed results. This might include metrics summaries, customer testimonials, or third-party validation. Maximum 3 files.”

Specify formats

Tell entrants what file types you accept. This prevents format problems and signals what kind of materials you’re expecting.
Example: “Accepted formats: PDF, JPG, PNG. Maximum 5MB per file.”

For video: “Upload video to YouTube or Vimeo and provide the link. Maximum 2 minutes.”

Specify quantities

Limits prevent entrants from uploading everything they have. They also signal what level of documentation is expected.
Example: “Upload up to 5 images showing your work. Include brief captions describing what each image shows.”

Distinguish required from optional

Not all material requests need to be mandatory. Core evidence might be required; supplementary context might be optional. Make the distinction clear.

Example: “Required: At least one form of evidence supporting your claimed outcomes. Optional: Customer testimonials, media coverage, or third-party recognition.”

Explain the purpose

When entrants understand why materials are requested, they provide more relevant uploads.
Example: “Judges will review these materials to verify claims made in your written responses. Provide evidence that supports your most important outcomes.”

Handling different material types

Different material types require different handling. Plan for format, access, and review considerations.

Images

Images are generally easy to handle. Specify common formats (JPG, PNG), reasonable size limits (2–5MB), and maximum quantities. Consider whether you need print-resolution images or whether web-quality suffices.

Require captions or descriptions so judges understand what they’re seeing. An unlabelled image may be meaningless without context.

Documents

PDFs are the safest document format, they display consistently across systems. Specify page limits or request summaries rather than complete documents. A “maximum 5 pages” limit forces entrants to prioritise key information.

Video

Video files are large and may cause upload problems. Consider requesting links to hosted video (YouTube, Vimeo) rather than direct uploads. This also allows judges to stream rather than download.

Set duration limits and enforce them. Judges won’t watch 15-minute videos. Specify maximum length, typically 1–3 minutes, and communicate that content beyond this limit won’t be reviewed.

Links and online content

For work that exists online, websites, applications, social media campaigns, links may be more appropriate than screenshots. But links can break, and online content can change.

Consider requesting both: a link for judges who want to explore, plus screenshots capturing the work as it existed at submission time.

Audio

Audio materials are less common but may be relevant for podcasts, music, voice work, or audio branding. Similar to video, consider hosting links rather than uploads, and set duration limits.

Making materials accessible to judges

Materials only help if judges can access and review them easily.

Centralise access

Judges should find all materials for an entry in one place, linked directly from the entry they’re evaluating. Hunting for materials across systems or emails reduces review likelihood.

Most awards platforms display “submission data” alongside written responses.

Ensure files open

Test that uploaded files actually open. Corrupted uploads, broken links, or format problems happen. Catching these during screening rather than judging prevents judge frustration and ensures materials are available when needed.

Provide context

Materials without context may be meaningless. Ensure entrants provide captions, descriptions, or explanations for what materials show and why they’re relevant.

When presenting materials to judges, include whatever context entrants provided. A customer testimonial attributed to “Operations Director, Major Retailer” is more useful than an unattributed quote.

Consider review burden

If every entry includes substantial supporting materials, judge workload increases significantly. Calculate what you’re asking judges to review across all their assigned entries. Twenty entries with 5 images, 2 documents, and a video each is substantial.

Match material requests to the time judges have available. If workload is already heavy, limit material requirements accordingly.

Screening materials before judging

Just as written entries benefit from pre-judging screening, supporting materials should be reviewed before judges see them.

Verify files work

Check that uploads open correctly, links function, and video plays. Flag problems for follow-up with entrants while there’s still time to fix them.

Check relevance

Review whether materials are actually relevant to the entry. Occasionally, entrants upload incorrect files, materials for different projects, or content that doesn’t match what was described.

Confirm permissions

If materials include third-party content, customer logos, testimonials, copyrighted materials, entrants should have permission to share them. While detailed verification isn’t always practical, obvious problems (using competitor branding, clearly copyrighted content) should be flagged.

Standardise presentation

If possible, present materials to judges in consistent formats. If some entrants uploaded PDFs and others uploaded Word documents, converting all to PDF creates consistency. If some provided video links and others uploaded files, ensuring all are accessible the same way helps judges.

Weighing materials in evaluation

Clarify how supporting materials factor into judging.

Evidence supporting claims

Most commonly, materials support evaluation of other criteria. If “evidence quality” is a criterion, strong supporting materials improve that score. If materials substantiate claims made under “impact” or “results,” they strengthen those scores.

In this model, materials don’t have separate scores, they enhance or diminish scores on related criteria.

Standalone evaluation

For creative or visual categories, materials might be evaluated directly. The quality of campaign imagery or product design is assessed on its own merits, not just as evidence supporting written claims.

In this model, materials may have dedicated scoring criteria.

Tiebreaker or enhancement

Some programs treat materials as tiebreakers, used when entries are otherwise comparable, or as enhancement that can lift but not replace strong written content.
Whatever approach you use, communicate it to judges so they weight materials appropriately.

Common mistakes to avoid

Requesting materials for their own sake

Every material request should serve a purpose. If you can’t articulate how materials will help judges evaluate entries, don’t request them.
Making everything mandatory

Not every entry benefits from the same materials. Creative entries need visual evidence; analytical entries may not. Consider which materials are essential versus helpful, and make only essentials mandatory.

Ignoring practical constraints

Materials require storage, organisation, and delivery to judges. Large volumes of large files create technical challenges. Ensure your systems can handle what you’re requesting.

Forgetting about judge time

Materials that judges don’t have time to review provide no value. Be realistic about what judges will actually examine, and limit requests accordingly.
Providing no guidance on expectations

When entrants don’t know what’s expected, they either under-provide or over-provide. Clear guidance on types, quantities, and purpose produces better, more consistent uploads.

Supporting materials should strengthen entries, not burden them. Request what genuinely helps judges evaluate, specify requirements clearly, ensure materials are accessible and usable, and respect the time constraints everyone faces. The best supporting materials are ones that judges are glad to have, evidence that clarifies, validates, and demonstrates in ways that written responses alone cannot achieve.

Frequently Asked Questions

The most valuable supporting materials provide evidence that strengthens the claims made in the written submission. These may include performance dashboards, customer testimonials, before-and-after comparisons, visual examples of the work, third-party recognition, or concise videos that demonstrate results.

Supporting materials should add information that text alone cannot easily communicate, making it easier for judges to verify achievements.

Supporting materials help judges evaluate entries by providing evidence, context, and credibility beyond the written responses. A customer testimonial, visual comparison, or independent report can often demonstrate impact more effectively than descriptive language alone.

When used well, these materials strengthen confidence in the claims being made without increasing the amount of written content judges need to assess.

Award programmes should avoid requesting lengthy reports, raw datasets, duplicate versions of written responses, confidential information, unusual file formats, or open-ended uploads with no guidance. These materials often increase workload without improving judging.

Instead, organisers should request concise, relevant evidence that directly supports the evaluation criteria.

Organisers should clearly explain what materials are required, acceptable file formats, quantity limits, file sizes, and whether each upload is mandatory or optional. Explaining why the materials are being requested also helps entrants provide more relevant evidence.

Clear requirements create more consistent submissions and reduce administrative issues before judging begins.

Images should be high quality and include captions explaining what they show. Documents are generally best submitted as concise PDFs rather than lengthy reports, while videos should usually be limited to one to three minutes and shared through reliable hosting platforms where appropriate.

Choosing accessible formats makes supporting materials easier for judges to review within the available judging time.

Yes. Supporting materials should be checked during the eligibility or screening stage to confirm files open correctly, links work, uploads match the submission, and any necessary permissions appear to be in place.

Pre-judging review prevents technical problems from disrupting the judging process and ensures all judges receive consistent supporting information.

Supporting materials should primarily be used to verify and strengthen the claims made in the written entry. In most award programmes, they support the assessment of criteria such as impact, evidence, or results rather than replacing the written submission.

For creative or design categories, the supporting materials themselves may also form part of the judging criteria where the work is best evaluated visually.

Common mistakes include making every upload mandatory, requesting materials judges will not realistically review, accepting inaccessible file formats, failing to explain expectations, and asking for evidence that duplicates the written submission.

The strongest supporting material requirements focus on quality rather than quantity, ensuring every requested file has a clear purpose in helping judges evaluate the entry.

Kristal Ó Gribín

Co-founder of The Awards Platform | 20 years in digital marketing, customer engagement and product management. Exploring how industry awards are designed, managed and used to recognise achievement, with real-world examples and practical insights for awards organisers.