How to handle AI-generated or low-effort award entries

The Awards Platform - Evaluating quality vs. low-effort submissions

Low-effort entries aren’t new. Awards programs have always received submissions that feel rushed, generic, or superficial, entries where the entrant clearly didn’t invest much time or thought. What’s changed is speed. AI tools now enable the production of polished-sounding, vague content in seconds rather than hours.

This creates a challenge for program organisers, but perhaps not the challenge it first appears to be. The instinct is to focus on detection, identifying which entries were AI-generated and penalising them accordingly. This approach is both technically difficult and strategically misguided.

The real issue isn’t who or what wrote an entry. It’s whether judges can evaluate genuine achievements based on what was submitted. A thoughtfully crafted AI-assisted entry that provides specific evidence and clear outcomes is more valuable than a hastily written human entry filled with vague claims. The problem isn’t the tool; it’s the substance.

This guide covers how to handle AI-generated and low-effort entries through design rather than detection, creating entry processes where quality is the path of least resistance and weak submissions are obvious regardless of how they were produced.

Why detection is the wrong focus

The instinct to detect and penalise AI-generated entries is understandable but problematic for several reasons.

Detection is unreliable

AI detection tools exist, but they’re inconsistent. They produce false positives (flagging human-written content as AI-generated) and false negatives (missing AI-generated content). As AI tools improve, detection becomes harder. Building policy around unreliable detection creates more problems than it solves.

Accusing an entrant of AI use based on flawed detection damages relationships and invites disputes. Even if you’re right, proving it is difficult. Even if you can prove it, defining exactly what’s prohibited is complicated, is AI-assisted editing prohibited? Grammar checking? Research assistance?

The line is increasingly blurry

Where does human writing end and AI assistance begin? Many professionals now use AI tools for drafting, editing, research, and refinement. Prohibiting AI entirely may be unenforceable and increasingly unrealistic. Allowing some AI use but not others requires distinctions that are difficult to define and impossible to verify.

A blanket ban on AI pushes the problem underground rather than solving it. Entrants who use AI will simply be more careful about avoiding detection, while entrants who don’t may be disadvantaged by competing against polished AI-assisted submissions.

The wrong question entirely

Focusing on AI use asks: “How was this written?” The relevant question is: “Does this submission give judges what they need to evaluate genuine achievements?”

An AI-generated entry that provides specific metrics, clear methodology, and verifiable evidence is more useful than a human-written entry filled with marketing language and unsubstantiated claims. The production method matters less than the outcome.

Reframing the problem: substance over production

The real concern with AI-generated entries isn’t that AI wrote them, it’s that AI makes it easy to produce content that sounds impressive but says nothing. Fluent paragraphs with confident claims, proper grammar, and professional tone can be generated instantly, without any actual achievement to describe.

But this isn’t uniquely an AI problem. Marketing teams have always produced polished copy that obscures rather than reveals. PR professionals have always crafted impressive-sounding narratives around modest achievements. The difference is volume and speed, not kind.

The solution is the same regardless of production method: design entry processes that require substance rather than prose. When entries must provide specific evidence, verifiable claims, and concrete details, weak submissions become obvious, whether they were produced by AI, by marketing teams, or by well-intentioned entrants who simply didn’t understand what was needed.

Design-based prevention

Entry form design is your primary tool for encouraging substantive submissions and discouraging low-effort ones. The goal is making quality the easiest path, not catching cheaters.

Require specificity

Vague questions invite vague answers. Specific questions require specific responses.
Vague: “Describe your achievements.”
Specific: “What measurable outcomes did this project achieve? Include specific metrics, the methodology used to measure them, timeframes, and comparison points (before/after or versus benchmark).”

The second version is harder to answer with generic AI content because it demands particular information. An AI tool can generate fluent prose about “significant improvements” instantly, but it can’t invent your specific NPS scores, resolution time reductions, or customer retention rates.

Ask for evidence, not just claims

Claims are easy to generate; evidence is harder to fabricate. Entry forms that explicitly request substantiation produce submissions that judges can actually evaluate.

Claim-focused: “What impact did your work have?”

Evidence-focused: “What evidence supports the outcomes you’ve claimed? Include methodology for metrics, third-party validation, or testimonials from customers or stakeholders who experienced the results.”

When entrants know evidence is required, they must either provide real substantiation or submit obviously weak entries. Either outcome is better than polished claims judges can’t verify.

Use component-based structure

Breaking entries into distinct components with specific questions for each makes template-based responses less effective. An entry form with separate questions for context, approach, results, and evidence requires engagement with each element rather than allowing a single narrative to cover (or obscure) everything.

This structure works against both AI generation and lazy human writing. Generic content must be adapted for each section, which requires thought and specificity that vague prompts don’t demand.
Request concrete details that require knowledge
Certain questions are difficult to answer without genuine familiarity with the work.

Examples:

“What was the most significant obstacle you encountered, and what specific decision did you make to address it?”
“Name one thing you would do differently if you could repeat this project, and explain why.”
“Describe a moment when you weren’t sure this approach would work. What convinced you to continue?”

These questions require reflection and specific memory that generic content can’t provide. Answers reveal whether the entrant genuinely understands the work being submitted.

Set word limits that force prioritisation

When space is unlimited, padding is easy. When word limits force choices, entrants must decide what matters most. This prioritisation reveals understanding, or exposes its absence.
A 200-word limit for describing outcomes forces entrants to identify their most important results rather than listing everything in vague terms. The discipline of constraint produces clearer, more evaluable content.

Handling entries that still feel generic

Despite good entry design, some submissions will still feel generic or low-effort. How should program s respond?

Let judging handle it

Well-designed judging criteria naturally penalise weak submissions. If “evidence quality” or “specificity of outcomes” are evaluation criteria, entries with vague claims and no substantiation score poorly regardless of how they were produced.

This approach is fair, consistent, and defensible. Entries aren’t rejected for how they were written but for failing to meet evaluation standards. The outcome is the same, weak entries don’t succeed, without requiring detection or accusation.

Focus on evidence gaps, not writing style

When reviewing entries that seem generic, look for specific deficiencies rather than stylistic suspicions. Does the entry provide verifiable metrics? Are claims supported with methodology? Are there concrete details that demonstrate genuine knowledge of the work?

Feedback based on evidence gaps is constructive and actionable: “Your entry would be strengthened by specific metrics and third-party validation.” Feedback based on writing style suspicions invites dispute: “This sounds AI-generated.”

Consider clarification requests

For borderline entries in competitive categories, program s can request additional information. “Please provide the specific methodology used to calculate your claimed customer satisfaction improvement” tests whether entrants can substantiate their submissions.

Genuine entrants welcome the opportunity to strengthen their entry. Entrants who can’t provide additional substance reveal the weakness of their original submission.

When AI assistance isn’t a problem

Not all AI use in entry writing is problematic. Clear thinking about when AI assistance is acceptable helps set appropriate expectations.

Drafting and editing

Using AI to improve grammar, clarify phrasing, or refine prose doesn’t undermine entry quality. The substance comes from the entrant; the tool helps communicate it clearly. This is little different from having a colleague review and edit a submission.

Research and structure

Using AI to research what makes strong entries, understand category requirements, or structure responses effectively can improve submission quality without fabricating achievements. Better-prepared entrants produce better entries.

Translation and accessibility

For non-native English speakers, AI assistance may enable participation that language barriers would otherwise prevent. Penalising this use would disadvantage entrants unfairly.

The line that matters

The meaningful line isn’t between human and AI writing, it’s between substantiated and unsubstantiated claims. An entry with genuine achievements, specific evidence, and verifiable outcomes is valuable regardless of how it was drafted. An entry with vague claims and no evidence is weak regardless of whether a human or AI produced it.

Communication and expectations

Clear communication about expectations helps entrants understand what’s required without program s needing to police production methods.

Focus guidance on substance requirements

Entry guidance should emphasise what judges need, not how entries should be produced.
Example: “Judges evaluate specific, measurable outcomes supported by credible evidence. General claims without substantiation score lower regardless of how well they’re written. Strong entries include concrete metrics, clear methodology, and third-party validation where available.”

This guidance applies pressure toward substance without mentioning AI or attempting to regulate production methods.

Acknowledge the reality

Some program s choose to acknowledge AI explicitly while focusing on substance requirements.

Example: “You may use any tools you find helpful in preparing your submission. However, judges evaluate specific evidence of genuine achievements. Entries that lack verifiable outcomes, concrete metrics, or credible substantiation will not score well, regardless of how polished they appear.”

This approach accepts that AI use will happen while making clear that it won’t compensate for lack of substance.

Avoid unenforceable prohibitions

Policies that prohibit AI use entirely are difficult to enforce and may create more problems than they solve. If you can’t reliably detect violations or fairly adjudicate accusations, the prohibition adds friction without benefit.

Better to design entry requirements that make substance necessary than to create rules you can’t enforce.

Screening and review processes

Pre-judging screening can identify entries that may warrant closer attention without requiring AI detection.

Completeness checks

Review whether entries have actually addressed what was asked. Submissions that respond to questions with generic content rather than specific answers may benefit from follow-up requests for clarification.

Evidence verification

For finalists or shortlisted entries, verify key claims. Contact customer references. Check publicly available information against claimed outcomes. Review supporting documentation for credibility.

Verification catches weak entries regardless of production method. It also signals to future entrants that claims will be checked, encouraging substantiation from the start.

Pattern recognition

If multiple entries contain similar language or structure, this may indicate template-based submissions. This is worth noting but not necessarily problematic, the question is whether each entry provides substance specific to the work being described.

The long-term perspective

AI capabilities will continue to improve. Today’s detection methods will become obsolete. The sustainable approach isn’t technological arms race but structural design that makes substance necessary.

Quality entry design becomes more important

As AI makes fluent writing easier, entry design must work harder to elicit specific, verifiable information. The skills that matter shift from detecting AI to designing questions AI can’t answer without genuine achievement input.

Evidence and verification gain importance

When anyone can produce polished prose, evidence becomes the differentiator. program s that emphasise substantiation, verification, and third-party validation will better identify genuine excellence than program s focused on writing quality.
The competitive landscape shifts

Entrants who view AI as a shortcut will produce generic submissions that fail against evidence requirements. Entrants who view AI as a tool for clearer communication of genuine achievements will produce stronger entries. Over time, this dynamic rewards substance and penalises empty polish.

Practical guidance for program organisers
Bringing these principles together, here’s practical guidance for handling AI-generated and low-effort entries.

Design entry forms that require substance

Use specific questions that demand particular information. Require evidence and methodology. Break submissions into components that each need genuine engagement. Set word limits that force prioritisation.

Weight evidence in judging criteria

Include “quality of evidence” or “substantiation of claims” as explicit evaluation dimensions. Ensure judges understand that polished prose without proof should score lower than clear evidence presented simply.

Provide clear guidance on expectations

Tell entrants what judges need. Emphasise specificity, evidence, and verification. Make clear that general claims won’t suffice regardless of how well they’re written.

Avoid detection-focused approaches

Don’t invest in AI detection tools or policies that require identifying how entries were produced. Focus on whether entries provide what judges need, not how they were created.

Verify where it matters

For finalists or winners, verify key claims. This catches weak entries, deters fabrication, and signals that substance matters.

Let judging do its job

Well-designed criteria penalise weak entries naturally. Trust the evaluation process rather than trying to pre-filter based on production method.

The goal isn’t eliminating AI from the entry process. It’s ensuring that judges can evaluate genuine achievements based on credible evidence. Entry design that accomplishes this goal handles both AI-generated and low-effort submissions, making the distinction between them largely irrelevant.

Frequently Asked Questions

Rather than focusing on AI detection, award programs should focus on whether submissions provide enough evidence for judges to evaluate genuine achievements. AI detection tools are unreliable, and the line between AI assistance and human writing is increasingly difficult to define.

A stronger approach is to design entry forms that reward specificity, evidence, and verifiable outcomes, regardless of how the submission was drafted.

The value of an award entry lies in the quality of the achievements it demonstrates, not the tool used to write it. An AI-assisted submission that includes measurable results, credible evidence, and clear methodology is far more useful to judges than a human-written entry filled with vague marketing claims.

Judges should evaluate what is presented, not how it was produced.

Well-designed entry forms make generic responses difficult by asking for specific metrics, methodologies, comparison points, evidence, and reflections based on first-hand experience. These requirements encourage entrants to provide genuine information that cannot be generated through generic prompts alone.

The more specific the questions, the easier it becomes for judges to distinguish substantive entries from superficial ones.

Questions that require detailed knowledge of the project are much harder to answer with generic content. For example, asking about a significant obstacle, a key decision, lessons learned, or what would be done differently encourages thoughtful, experience-based responses.

These reflective questions reveal whether the entrant has genuine insight into the work rather than relying on polished but superficial writing.

AI can be a useful tool for improving grammar, refining structure, conducting research, or translating content, provided the submission accurately reflects genuine achievements. The issue is not AI assistance itself but whether the final entry contains credible, verifiable evidence.

Entries supported by measurable outcomes and substantiation remain strong regardless of the writing tools used.

Judges should focus on objective evidence rather than writing style. Instead of asking whether an entry sounds AI-generated, they should assess whether claims are supported by metrics, methodology, testimonials, or other verifiable proof.

Scoring based on evidence quality provides a fairer and more defensible evaluation than attempting to identify how the content was written.

A complete ban on AI is difficult to enforce and may unfairly disadvantage entrants who use AI responsibly for editing or accessibility purposes. Instead, programs should set clear expectations that all claims must be supported with credible evidence and measurable outcomes.

This approach keeps the focus on submission quality rather than the technology used during preparation

The most effective strategy is to require evidence throughout the submission process. Entry forms should ask for specific results, methodologies, supporting documentation, and third-party validation where appropriate, while judges should verify important claims for shortlisted entries.

By making substantiation central to both the entry form and judging process, programs naturally reward genuine achievements and discourage empty, AI-generated polish.

Kristal Ó Gribín

Co-founder of The Awards Platform | 20 years in digital marketing, customer engagement and product management. Exploring how industry awards are designed, managed and used to recognise achievement, with real-world examples and practical insights for awards organisers.